How ID Theft Prevention “Crushed” A Man’s Credit Score

Tuesday, Dec 11, 18

We often hear about how Id Theft Prevention tools protect consumers’ credit report and scores. I recently spoke to a consumer who experienced the exact opposite.

I recently spoke to a young man; I will call him Sam, who was completely disgusted about a recent major drop to his credit score. As it turns out, the drop to Sam’s credit score was related to a recent 30-day late payment that was added to his credit report from his credit card company. Sam’s disgust was related to why his credit card company marked him late.

Sam’s issue with his credit card company started during this past Christmas holiday. While dealing with the hustle and bustle of the season, Sam took the time to sneak away from his family to make his monthly credit card payment online. When Sam entered his login credentials, he found out something was wrong. After confirming he entered his login credentials correctly, Sam discovered that he was not able to access his online account. Frustrated, Sam called the company and discovered his online account was frozen by his credit card company due to what they called unauthorized/fraudulent activity.

Freaked out, Sam wanted to get new login credentials so he could get online to make a payment and dispute any unauthorized charges. Sam’s credit card company refused to reactivate his online account and they said their policy was that he had to go to a branch and prove his identity. Sam informed the bank that he had a house full of guests and he could not drive 4 hours to their nearest branch. His credit card company said they would mail him a statement and switch him to paper statements going forward so he then would be able to make payments and see all the charges. Sam agreed and went back to his family activities.

After waiting a week or two, Sam did not receive his credit card statement in the mail so he called his credit card company. On this call, they indicated he was currently past due for his December payment and now his January payment was also due. Sam was upset because he did not get the paper statement he was waiting for so he was unable to verify the charges and make his payment. Not wanting to have a past due account, Sam made a payment by phone. His credit card company confirmed he will be getting his monthly statements going forward and all was fine.

Sam thought he was fine until he received an alert from a credit monitoring company. This alert indicated a late payment was added to his credit report and Sam discovered the late payment was from his credit card company. Sam looked at his updated credit score and he said the new late payment “crushed” his credit score.

Sam’s credit card company said they were protecting him from unauthorized use of his credit card but according to Sam, their protection ended up getting him a 30 day late and subsequent lower credit score. If this ever happens to you, I suggest to make an over the phone payment immediately and then stay on top of the issue daily until you are certain it has been resolved.

About the Author

Credit Reporting / Scoring Expert, Chris McConville is the President of Credit Education at and founder of where he works as an Expert Credit Witness in both Federal and State Court. With working in the credit and mortgage fields since 1991, he’s dedicated to sharing his knowledge to educate consumers.

we know credit

Proud Member of

National Association of Credit Services Organizations


Download App on iTunes Download our App Google Play